2 Commits

Include renames

Author	SHA1	Message	Date
Chris Lu	a6d72bc272	s3api: delete orphaned chunks only when the entry is confirmed absent (#11389) ... * s3api: test for chunks deleted under an entry the filer committed Issue #11387: the filer can report a create failure after inserting the entry (e.g. a parent-directory creation failing post-insert). The error arrives in the response rather than as a transport status, so it maps to a definitive error and putToFiler deletes the chunks of the live entry. * s3api: confirmCreateLanded also reports a confirmed-absent entry The verification a failed create runs can answer both directions: the entry matching the uploaded chunks proves the write landed, and an authoritative not-found proves the uploaded chunks are orphaned. Return both outcomes so the cleanup path can gate on the fact rather than the error class. An empty upload can never prove a landing, so a zero-chunk entry match no longer upgrades the outcome. * s3api: delete orphaned chunks only when the entry is confirmed absent A failed create no longer skips verification based on the error class: the filer can fail after inserting the entry (issue #11387) and a partially-applied routed transaction can leave it behind too, both surfacing as definitive errors. Every failed create now resolves the entry's fate, and the uploaded chunks are deleted only when the entry is confirmed absent; anything unverifiable keeps them for vacuum. * s3api: confirm absence on every filer the create could have committed on A lock-path create fails over across filers, so the entry can live on a replica the routed owner has not caught up to; one not-found does not prove absence. The confirmation now queries the owner, the prior owner, and the failover set, declaring absent only when none of them has the entry. * s3api: bound the reconciliation lookups confirmCreateLanded runs The lookups ran on context.Background() under the object write lock, so a connected filer that never replies could stall the write path. One timeout now covers the whole enumeration; an expired budget fails the remaining lookups as uncertain, which keeps the chunks.	2026-09-18 12:30:07 -07:00
Chris Lu	ce1e0dc30a	s3api: don't delete chunks when CreateEntry outcome is ambiguous (#11376) ... * s3api: map ambiguous filer transport errors to retryable 503 Canceled, DeadlineExceeded and Unavailable can be returned after the filer applied the write, so the outcome is ambiguous. Reporting them as a 4xx tells the client not to retry; report ServiceUnavailable instead. * s3api: verify entry existence before deleting orphaned chunks A failed CreateEntry can still have landed on the filer when the error is a transport failure, and entryCreated=false would tombstone chunks a live entry references, leaving a dangling pointer that survives only because reads pass readDeleted=true until vacuum reclaims the needle. Before deleting, look the entry up: if it is stored with the same chunks, the write succeeded; if the lookup cannot be answered, keep the chunks for vacuum to reclaim; only a confirmed absence still cleans up. * s3api: regression tests for ambiguous CreateEntry outcomes Covers the three post-create-failure cases in putToFiler: the entry landed despite the error (treat as success, keep chunks), the entry is confirmed absent (delete orphans), and the outcome is unverifiable (keep chunks, return error). * volume: count reads served from deleted needles A readDeleted read succeeding on a tombstoned needle is the signal that metadata still points at deleted data. Count it under a readDeletedNeedle handler label in both the Go and Rust volume servers so the condition is visible before vacuum turns it into a 404. * s3api: never delete chunks on an ambiguous create error Review feedback on the first fix showed verification could still go wrong in both directions: a stale or lagged lookup could report not-found for a committed entry, a prefix object stores its chunks on a directory entry, and filer-side manifestization rewrites the top-level chunk ids the comparison relied on. Rework the rule so the outcome classes are asymmetric: - A transport-level error (anything filerErrorToS3Error maps to a retryable 503) is ambiguous and never deletes chunks; the lookup can only upgrade the write to success. - Any other error is a definitive filer refusal and still cleans up. confirmCreateLanded asks the write owner first, resolves the stored entry through chunk manifests, requires an exact match of the uploaded file ids, and on success runs the finalize callback the failed create skipped (under the object write lock, with the same rmObject undo the create path uses). Zero-chunk writes stay ambiguous since they cannot be told apart by chunks. * s3api: cover definitive refusals and stale entries in put tests The confirmed-failure case now uses a definitive refusal so it still exercises orphan cleanup, and a new case keeps chunks when the stored entry belongs to an older object rather than this PUT. * volume: count deleted-needle reads once per request Streamed Go reads ran the deleted check in readNeedle and again in readNeedleDataInto, and non-streamed Rust reads in stream_info and the full-read fallback, double-counting one request. Count at the single entry probe each implementation takes per GET: readNeedle in Go, read_needle_stream_info in Rust. * s3api: run recovered-write rollback under the object lock Two follow-ups from review: ResolveChunkManifest returns traversed manifest blobs in its manifestChunks output, so requiring it empty rejected every manifestized landing; and the rmObject undo ran after the object write lock was released, so a concurrent newer write could be deleted between finalize failure and rollback. Compare only the resolved data chunks and keep the undo inside the lock. * s3api: verify, finalize and roll back recovered creates in one lock A lookup done before the object write lock let a concurrent PUT replace the entry between the chunk comparison and the finalize/rollback section, so a failed afterCreate could rmObject a newer write. Run the owner lookup, manifest resolution, chunk comparison, afterCreate and the conditional undo inside a single withObjectWriteLock section.	2026-09-17 19:58:49 -07:00