Commit Graph
6 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
Chris Lu dfd05d14cb refactor(filer): remove the inode->path index and the NFS gateway (#9724)
* fix(filer): derive inodes by hash instead of a snowflake sequencer

Compute the same inode the FUSE mount would: non-hard-linked entries hash path + crtime, hard links hash their shared HardLinkId so every link resolves to one inode. Removes the snowflake inodeSequencer and the SEAWEEDFS_FILER_SNOWFLAKE_ID knob; inodes are now deterministic across filers.

* chore: remove the experimental NFS gateway

The NFS frontend ('weed nfs') was the only consumer of the inode->path index. Remove the weed/server/nfs package, the command and its registration, the integration test harness, and the CI workflow; go mod tidy drops the willscott/go-nfs and go-nfs-client dependencies.

* refactor(filer): drop the inode->path index

With the NFS gateway gone, nothing reads it. A regular file's inode is a pure hash of its path and a hard link's is a hash of its shared HardLinkId -- both derivable on demand -- so the secondary KV index and its write/remove hooks are dead. Removes filer_inode_index.go and the recordInodeIndex hooks from the store wrapper.
2026-05-28 15:00:18 -07:00
Chris Lu 08d9193fe1 [nfs] Add NFS (#9067)
* add filer inode foundation for nfs

* nfs command skeleton

* add filer inode index foundation for nfs

* make nfs inode index hardlink aware

* add nfs filehandle and inode lookup plumbing

* add read-only nfs frontend foundation

* add nfs namespace mutation support

* add chunk-backed nfs write path

* add nfs protocol integration tests

* add stale handle nfs coverage

* complete nfs hardlink and failover coverage

* add nfs export access controls

* add nfs metadata cache invalidation

* fix nfs chunk read lookup routing

* fix nfs review findings and rename regression

* address pr 9067 review comments

- filer_inode: fail fast if the snowflake sequencer cannot start, and let
  operators override the 10-bit node id via SEAWEEDFS_FILER_SNOWFLAKE_ID
  to avoid multi-filer collisions
- filer_inode: drop the redundant retry loop in nextInode
- filerstore_wrapper: treat inode-index writes/removals as best-effort so
  a primary store success no longer surfaces as an operation failure
- filer_grpc_server_rename: defer overwritten-target chunk deletion until
  after CommitTransaction so a rolled-back rename does not strand live
  metadata pointing at freshly deleted chunks
- command/nfs: default ip.bind to loopback and require an explicit
  filer.path, so the experimental server does not expose the entire
  filer namespace on first run
- nfs integration_test: document why LinkArgs matches go-nfs's on-the-wire
  layout rather than RFC 1813 LINK3args

* mount: pre-allocate inode in Mkdir and Symlink

Mkdir and Symlink used to send filer_pb.CreateEntryRequest with
Attributes.Inode = 0. After PR 9067, the filer's CreateEntry now assigns
its own inode in that case, so the filer-side entry ends up with a
different inode than the one the mount allocates via inodeToPath.Lookup
and returns to the kernel. Once applyLocalMetadataEvent stores the
filer's entry in the meta cache, subsequent GetAttr calls read the
cached entry and hit the setAttrByPbEntry override at line 197 of
weedfs_attr.go, returning the filer-assigned inode instead of the
mount's local one. pjdfstest tests/rename/00.t (subtests 81/87/91)
caught this — it lstat'd a freshly-created directory/symlink, renamed
it, lstat'd again, and saw a different inode the second time.

createRegularFile already pre-allocates via inodeToPath.AllocateInode
and stamps it into the create request. Do the same thing in Mkdir and
Symlink so both sides agree on the object identity from the very first
request, and so GetAttr's cache path returns the same value as Mkdir /
Symlink's initial response.

* sequence: mask snowflake node id on int→uint32 conversion

CodeQL flagged the unchecked uint32(snowflakeId) cast in
NewSnowflakeSequencer as a potential truncation bug when snowflakeId is
sourced from user input (e.g. via SEAWEEDFS_FILER_SNOWFLAKE_ID). Mask
to the 10 bits the snowflake library actually uses so any caller-
supplied int is safely clamped into range.

* add test/nfs integration suite

Boots a real SeaweedFS cluster (master + volume + filer) plus the
experimental `weed nfs` frontend as subprocesses and drives it through
the NFSv3 wire protocol via go-nfs-client, mirroring the layout of
test/sftp. The tests run without a kernel NFS mount, privileged ports,
or any platform-specific tooling.

Coverage includes read/write round-trip, mkdir/rmdir, nested
directories, rename content preservation, overwrite + explicit
truncate, 3 MiB binary file, all-byte binary and empty files, symlink
round-trip, ReadDirPlus listing, missing-path remove, FSInfo sanity,
sequential appends, and readdir-after-remove.

Framework notes:

- Picks ephemeral ports with net.Listen("127.0.0.1:0") and passes
  -port.grpc explicitly so the default port+10000 convention cannot
  overflow uint16 on macOS.
- Pre-creates the /nfs_export directory via the filer HTTP API before
  starting the NFS server — the NFS server's ensureIndexedEntry check
  requires the export root to exist with a real entry, which filer.Root
  does not satisfy when the export path is "/".
- Reuses the same rpc.Client for mount and target so go-nfs-client does
  not try to re-dial via portmapper (which concatenates ":111" onto the
  address).

* ci: add NFS integration test workflow

Mirror test/sftp's workflow for the new test/nfs suite so PRs that touch
the NFS server, the inode filer plumbing it depends on, or the test
harness itself run the 14 NFSv3-over-RPC integration tests on Ubuntu
22.04 via `make test`.

* nfs: use append for buffer growth in Write and Truncate

The previous make+copy pattern reallocated the full buffer on every
extending write or truncate, giving O(N^2) behaviour for sequential
write loops. Switching to `append(f.content, make([]byte, delta)...)`
lets Go's amortized growth strategy absorb the repeated extensions.
Called out by gemini-code-assist on PR 9067.

* filer: honor caller cancellation in collectInodeIndexEntries

Dropping the WithoutCancel wrapper lets DeleteFolderChildren bail out of
the inode-index scan if the client disconnects mid-walk. The cleanup is
already treated as best-effort by the caller (it logs on error and
continues), so a cancelled walk just means the partial index rebuild is
skipped — the same failure mode as any other index write error.
Flagged as a DoS concern by gemini-code-assist on PR 9067.

* nfs: skip filer read on open when O_TRUNC is set

openFile used to unconditionally loadWritableContent for every writable
open and then discard the buffer if O_TRUNC was set. For large files
that is a pointless 64 MiB round-trip. Reorder the branches so we only
fetch existing content when the caller intends to keep it, and mark the
file dirty right away so the subsequent Close still issues the
truncating write. Called out by gemini-code-assist on PR 9067.

* nfs: allow Seek on O_APPEND files and document buffered write cap

Two related cleanups on filesystem.go:

- POSIX only restricts Write on an O_APPEND fd, not lseek. The existing
  Seek error ("append-only file descriptors may only seek to EOF")
  prevented read-and-write workloads that legitimately reposition the
  read cursor. Write already snaps the offset to EOF before persisting
  (see seaweedFile Write), so Seek can unconditionally accept any
  offset. Update the unit test that was asserting the old behaviour.
- Add a doc comment on maxBufferedWriteSize explaining that it is a
  per-file ceiling, the memory footprint it implies, and that the real
  fix for larger whole-file rewrites is streaming / multi-chunk support.

Both changes flagged by gemini-code-assist on PR 9067.

* nfs: guard offset before casting to int in Write

CodeQL flagged `int(f.offset) + len(p)` inside the Write growth path as
a potential overflow on architectures where `int` is 32-bit. The
existing check only bounded the post-cast value, which is too late.
Clamp f.offset against maxBufferedWriteSize before the cast and also
reject negative/overflowed endOffset results. Both branches fall
through to billy.ErrNotSupported, the same behaviour the caller gets
today for any out-of-range buffered write.

* nfs: compute Write endOffset in int64 to satisfy CodeQL

The previous guard bounded f.offset but left len(p) unchecked, so
CodeQL still flagged `int(f.offset) + len(p)` as a possible int-width
overflow path. Bound len(p) against maxBufferedWriteSize first, do the
addition in int64, and only cast down after the total has been clamped
against the buffer ceiling. Behaviour is unchanged: any out-of-range
write still returns billy.ErrNotSupported.

* ci: drop emojis from nfs-tests workflow summary

Plain-text step summary per user preference — no decorative glyphs in
the NFS CI output or checklist.

* nfs: annotate remaining DEV_PLAN TODOs with status

Three of the unchecked items are genuine follow-up PRs rather than
missing work in this one, and one was actually already done:

- Reuse chunk cache and mutation stream helpers without FUSE deps:
  checked off — the NFS server imports weed/filer.ReaderCache and
  weed/util/chunk_cache directly with no weed/mount or go-fuse imports.
- Extract shared read/write helpers from mount/WebDAV/SFTP: annotated
  as deferred to a separate refactor PR (touches four packages).
- Expand direct data-path writes beyond the 64 MiB buffered fallback:
  annotated as deferred — requires a streaming WRITE path.
- Shared lock state + lock tests: annotated as blocked upstream on
  go-nfs's missing NLM/NFSv4 lock state RPCs, matching the existing
  "Current Blockers" note.

* test/nfs: share port+readiness helpers with test/testutil

Drop the per-suite mustPickFreePort and waitForService re-implementations
in favor of testutil.MustAllocatePorts (atomic batch allocation; no
close-then-hope race) and testutil.WaitForPort / SeaweedMiniStartupTimeout.
Pull testutil in via a local replace directive so this standalone
seaweedfs-nfs-tests module can import the in-repo package without a
separate release.

Subprocess startup is still master + volume + filer + nfs — no switch to
weed mini yet, since mini does not know about the nfs frontend.

* nfs: stream writes to volume servers instead of buffering the whole file

Before this change the NFS write path held the full contents of every
writable open in memory:

  - OpenFile(write) called loadWritableContent which read the existing
    file into seaweedFile.content up to maxBufferedWriteSize (64 MiB)
  - each Write() extended content in-place
  - Close() uploaded the whole buffer as a single chunk via
    persistContent + AssignVolume

The 64 MiB ceiling made large NFS writes return NFS3ERR_NOTSUPP, and
even below the cap every Write paid a whole-file-in-memory cost. This
PR rewrites the write path to match how `weed filer` and the S3 gateway
persist data:

  - openFile(write) no longer loads the existing content at all; it
    only issues an UpdateEntry when O_TRUNC is set *and* the file is
    non-empty (so a fresh create+trunc is still zero-RPC)
  - Write() streams the caller's bytes straight to a volume server via
    one AssignVolume + one chunk upload, then atomically appends the
    resulting chunk to the filer entry through mutateEntry. Any
    previously inlined entry.Content is migrated to a chunk in the same
    update so the chunk list becomes the authoritative representation.
  - Truncate() becomes a direct mutateEntry (drop chunks past the new
    size, clip inline content, update FileSize) instead of resizing an
    in-memory buffer.
  - Close() is a no-op because everything was flushed inline.

The small-file fast path that the filer HTTP handler uses is preserved:
if the post-write size still fits in maxInlineWriteSize (4 MiB) and
the file has no existing chunks, we rewrite entry.Content directly and
skip the volume-server round-trip. This keeps single-shot tiny writes
(echo, small edits) cheap while completely removing the 64 MiB cap on
larger files. Read() now always reads through the chunk reader instead
of a local byte slice, so reads inside the same session see the freshly
appended data.

Drops the unused seaweedFile.content / dirty fields, the
maxBufferedWriteSize constant, and the loadWritableContent helper.
Updates TestSeaweedFileSystemSupportsNamespaceMutations expectations
to match the new "no extra O_TRUNC UpdateEntry on an empty file"
behavior (still 3 updates: Write + Chmod + Truncate).

* filer: extract shared gateway upload helper for NFS and WebDAV

Three filer-backed gateways (NFS, WebDAV, and mount) each had a local
saveDataAsChunk that wrapped operation.NewUploader().UploadWithRetry
with near-identical bodies: build AssignVolumeRequest, build
UploadOption, build genFileUrlFn with optional filerProxy rewriting,
call UploadWithRetry, validate the result, and call ToPbFileChunk.
Pull that body into filer.SaveGatewayDataAsChunk with a
GatewayChunkUploadRequest struct so both NFS and WebDAV can delegate
to one implementation.

- NFS's saveDataAsChunk is now a thin adapter that assembles the
  GatewayChunkUploadRequest from server options and calls the helper.
  The chunkUploader interface keeps working for test injection because
  the new GatewayChunkUploader interface is structurally identical.
- WebDAV's saveDataAsChunk is similarly a thin adapter — it drops the
  local operation.NewUploader call plus the AssignVolume/UploadOption
  scaffolding.
- mount is intentionally left alone. mount's saveDataAsChunk has two
  features that do not fit the shared helper (a pre-allocated file-id
  pool used to skip AssignVolume entirely, and a chunkCache
  write-through at offset 0 so future reads hit the mount's local
  cache), both of which are mount-specific.

Marks the Phase 2 "extract shared read/write helpers from mount,
WebDAV, and SFTP" DEV_PLAN item as done. The filer-level chunk read
path (NonOverlappingVisibleIntervals + ViewFromVisibleIntervals +
NewChunkReaderAtFromClient) was already shared.

* nfs: remove DESIGN.md and DEV_PLAN.md

The planning documents have served their purpose — all phase 1 and
phase 2 items are landed, phase 3 streaming writes are landed, phase 2
shared helpers are extracted, and the two remaining phase 4 items
(shared lock state + lock tests) are blocked upstream on
github.com/willscott/go-nfs which exposes no NLM or NFSv4 lock state
RPCs. The running decision log no longer reflects current code and
would just drift. The NFS wiki page
(https://github.com/seaweedfs/seaweedfs/wiki/NFS-Server) now carries
the overview, configuration surface, architecture notes, and known
limitations; the source is the source of truth for the rest.
2026-04-14 20:48:24 -07:00
8cde3d4486 Add data file compaction to iceberg maintenance (Phase 2) (#8503)
* Add iceberg_maintenance plugin worker handler (Phase 1)

Implement automated Iceberg table maintenance as a new plugin worker job
type. The handler scans S3 table buckets for tables needing maintenance
and executes operations in the correct Iceberg order: expire snapshots,
remove orphan files, and rewrite manifests.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* Add data file compaction to iceberg maintenance handler (Phase 2)

Implement bin-packing compaction for small Parquet data files:
- Enumerate data files from manifests, group by partition
- Merge small files using parquet-go (read rows, write merged output)
- Create new manifest with ADDED/DELETED/EXISTING entries
- Commit new snapshot with compaction metadata

Add 'compact' operation to maintenance order (runs before expire_snapshots),
configurable via target_file_size_bytes and min_input_files thresholds.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* Fix memory exhaustion in mergeParquetFiles by processing files sequentially

Previously all source Parquet files were loaded into memory simultaneously,
risking OOM when a compaction bin contained many small files. Now each file
is loaded, its rows are streamed into the output writer, and its data is
released before the next file is loaded — keeping peak memory proportional
to one input file plus the output buffer.

* Validate bucket/namespace/table names against path traversal

Reject names containing '..', '/', or '\' in Execute to prevent
directory traversal via crafted job parameters.

* Add filer address failover in iceberg maintenance handler

Try each filer address from cluster context in order instead of only
using the first one. This improves resilience when the primary filer
is temporarily unreachable.

* Add separate MinManifestsToRewrite config for manifest rewrite threshold

The rewrite_manifests operation was reusing MinInputFiles (meant for
compaction bin file counts) as its manifest count threshold. Add a
dedicated MinManifestsToRewrite field with its own config UI section
and default value (5) so the two thresholds can be tuned independently.

* Fix risky mtime fallback in orphan removal that could delete new files

When entry.Attributes is nil, mtime defaulted to Unix epoch (1970),
which would always be older than the safety threshold, causing the
file to be treated as eligible for deletion. Skip entries with nil
Attributes instead, matching the safer logic in operations.go.

* Fix undefined function references in iceberg_maintenance_handler.go

Use the exported function names (ShouldSkipDetectionByInterval,
BuildDetectorActivity, BuildExecutorActivity) matching their
definitions in vacuum_handler.go.

* Remove duplicated iceberg maintenance handler in favor of iceberg/ subpackage

The IcebergMaintenanceHandler and its compaction code in the parent
pluginworker package duplicated the logic already present in the
iceberg/ subpackage (which self-registers via init()). The old code
lacked stale-plan guards, proper path normalization, CAS-based xattr
updates, and error-returning parseOperations.

Since the registry pattern (default "all") makes the old handler
unreachable, remove it entirely. All functionality is provided by
iceberg.Handler with the reviewed improvements.

* Fix MinManifestsToRewrite clamping to match UI minimum of 2

The clamp reset values below 2 to the default of 5, contradicting the
UI's advertised MinValue of 2. Clamp to 2 instead.

* Sort entries by size descending in splitOversizedBin for better packing

Entries were processed in insertion order which is non-deterministic
from map iteration. Sorting largest-first before the splitting loop
improves bin packing efficiency by filling bins more evenly.

* Add context cancellation check to drainReader loop

The row-streaming loop in drainReader did not check ctx between
iterations, making long compaction merges uncancellable. Check
ctx.Done() at the top of each iteration.

* Fix splitOversizedBin to always respect targetSize limit

The minFiles check in the split condition allowed bins to grow past
targetSize when they had fewer than minFiles entries, defeating the
OOM protection. Now bins always split at targetSize, and a trailing
runt with fewer than minFiles entries is merged into the previous bin.

* Add integration tests for iceberg table maintenance plugin worker

Tests start a real weed mini cluster, create S3 buckets and Iceberg
table metadata via filer gRPC, then exercise the iceberg.Handler
operations (ExpireSnapshots, RemoveOrphans, RewriteManifests) against
the live filer. A full maintenance cycle test runs all operations in
sequence and verifies metadata consistency.

Also adds exported method wrappers (testing_api.go) so the integration
test package can call the unexported handler methods.

* Fix splitOversizedBin dropping files and add source path to drainReader errors

The runt-merge step could leave leading bins with fewer than minFiles
entries (e.g. [80,80,10,10] with targetSize=100, minFiles=2 would drop
the first 80-byte file). Replace the filter-based approach with an
iterative merge that folds any sub-minFiles bin into its smallest
neighbor, preserving all eligible files.

Also add the source file path to drainReader error messages so callers
can identify which Parquet file caused a read/write failure.

* Harden integration test error handling

- s3put: fail immediately on HTTP 4xx/5xx instead of logging and
  continuing
- lookupEntry: distinguish NotFound (return nil) from unexpected RPC
  errors (fail the test)
- writeOrphan and orphan creation in FullMaintenanceCycle: check
  CreateEntryResponse.Error in addition to the RPC error

* go fmt

---------

Co-authored-by: Copilot <copilot@github.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-03-15 11:27:42 -07:00
Chris Lu f3c5ba3cd6 feat(filer): add lazy directory listing for remote mounts (#8615)
* feat(filer): add lazy directory listing for remote mounts

Directory listings on remote mounts previously only queried the local
filer store. With lazy mounts the listing was empty; with eager mounts
it went stale over time.

Add on-demand directory listing that fetches from remote and caches
results with a 5-minute TTL:

- Add `ListDirectory` to `RemoteStorageClient` interface (delimiter-based,
  single-level listing, separate from recursive `Traverse`)
- Implement in S3, GCS, and Azure backends using each platform's
  hierarchical listing API
- Add `maybeLazyListFromRemote` to filer: before each directory listing,
  check if the directory is under a remote mount with an expired cache,
  fetch from remote, persist entries to the local store, then let existing
  listing logic run on the populated store
- Use singleflight to deduplicate concurrent requests for the same directory
- Skip local-only entries (no RemoteEntry) to avoid overwriting unsynced uploads
- Errors are logged and swallowed (availability over consistency)

* refactor: extract xattr key to constant xattrRemoteListingSyncedAt

* feat: make listing cache TTL configurable per mount via listing_cache_ttl_seconds

Add listing_cache_ttl_seconds field to RemoteStorageLocation protobuf.
When 0 (default), lazy directory listing is disabled for that mount.
When >0, enables on-demand directory listing with the specified TTL.

Expose as -listingCacheTTL flag on remote.mount command.

* refactor: address review feedback for lazy directory listing

- Add context.Context to ListDirectory interface and all implementations
- Capture startTime before remote call for accurate TTL tracking
- Simplify S3 ListDirectory using ListObjectsV2PagesWithContext
- Make maybeLazyListFromRemote return void (errors always swallowed)
- Remove redundant trailing-slash path manipulation in caller
- Update tests to match new signatures

* When an existing entry has Remote != nil, we should merge remote metadata   into it rather than replacing it.

* fix(gcs): wrap ListDirectory iterator error with context

The raw iterator error was returned without bucket/path context,
making it harder to debug. Wrap it consistently with the S3 pattern.

* fix(s3): guard against nil pointer dereference in Traverse and ListDirectory

Some S3-compatible backends may return nil for LastModified, Size, or
ETag fields. Check for nil before dereferencing to prevent panics.

* fix(filer): remove blanket 2-minute timeout from lazy listing context

Individual SDK operations (S3, GCS, Azure) already have per-request
timeouts and retry policies. The blanket timeout could cut off large
directory listings mid-operation even though individual pages were
succeeding.

* fix(filer): preserve trace context in lazy listing with WithoutCancel

Use context.WithoutCancel(ctx) instead of context.Background() so
trace/span values from the incoming request are retained for
distributed tracing, while still decoupling cancellation.

* fix(filer): use Store.FindEntry for internal lookups, add Uid/Gid to files, fix updateDirectoryListingSyncedAt

- Use f.Store.FindEntry instead of f.FindEntry for staleness check and
  child lookups to avoid unnecessary lazy-fetch overhead
- Set OS_UID/OS_GID on new file entries for consistency with directories
- In updateDirectoryListingSyncedAt, use Store.UpdateEntry for existing
  directories instead of CreateEntry to avoid deleteChunksIfNotNew and
  NotifyUpdateEvent side effects

* fix(filer): distinguish not-found from store errors in lazy listing

Previously, any error from Store.FindEntry was treated as "not found,"
which could cause entry recreation/overwrite on transient DB failures.
Now check for filer_pb.ErrNotFound explicitly and skip entries or
bail out on real store errors.

* refactor(filer): use errors.Is for ErrNotFound comparisons
2026-03-13 09:36:54 -07:00
Peter DoddandChris Lu 146a090754 filer: propagate lazy metadata deletes to remote mounts (#8522)
* filer: propagate lazy metadata deletes to remote mounts

Delete operations now call the remote backend for mounted remote-only entries before removing filer metadata, keeping remote state aligned and preserving retry semantics on remote failures.

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: harden remote delete metadata recovery

Persist remote-delete metadata pendings so local entry removal can be retried after failures, and return explicit errors when remote client resolution fails to prevent silent local-only deletes.

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: streamline remote delete client lookup and logging

Avoid a redundant mount trie traversal by resolving the remote client directly from the matched mount location, and add parity logging for successful remote directory deletions.

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: harden pending remote metadata deletion flow

Retry pending-marker writes before local delete, fail closed when marking cannot be persisted, and start remote pending reconciliation only after the filer store is initialised to avoid nil store access.

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: avoid lazy fetch in pending metadata reconciliation

Use a local-only entry lookup during pending remote metadata reconciliation so cache misses do not trigger remote lazy fetches.

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: serialise concurrent index read-modify-write in pending metadata deletion

Add remoteMetadataDeletionIndexMu to Filer and acquire it for the full
read→mutate→commit sequence in markRemoteMetadataDeletionPending and
clearRemoteMetadataDeletionPending, preventing concurrent goroutines
from overwriting each other's index updates.

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: start remote deletion reconciliation loop in NewFiler

Move the background goroutine for pending remote metadata deletion
reconciliation from SetStore (where it was gated by sync.Once) to
NewFiler alongside the existing loopProcessingDeletion goroutine.

The sync.Once approach was problematic: it buried a goroutine launch
as a side effect of a setter, was unrecoverable if the goroutine
panicked, could race with store initialisation, and coupled its
lifecycle to unrelated shutdown machinery. The existing nil-store
guard in reconcilePendingRemoteMetadataDeletions handles the window
before SetStore is called.

* filer: skip remote delete for replicated deletes from other filers

When isFromOtherCluster is true the delete was already propagated to
the remote backend by the originating filer. Repeating the remote
delete on every replica doubles API calls, and a transient remote
failure on the replica would block local metadata cleanup — leaving
filers inconsistent.

* filer: skip pending marking for directory remote deletes

Directory remote deletes are idempotent and do not need the
pending/reconcile machinery that was designed for file deletes where
the local metadata delete might fail after the remote object is
already removed.

* filer: propagate remote deletes for children in recursive folder deletion

doBatchDeleteFolderMetaAndData iterated child files but only called
NotifyUpdateEvent and collected chunks — it never called
maybeDeleteFromRemote for individual children. This left orphaned
objects in the remote backend when a directory containing remote-only
files was recursively deleted.

Also fix isFromOtherCluster being hardcoded to false in the recursive
call to doBatchDeleteFolderMetaAndData for subdirectories.

* filer: simplify pending remote deletion tracking to single index key

Replace the double-bookkeeping scheme (individual KV entry per path +
newline-delimited index key) with a single index key that stores paths
directly. This removes the per-path KV writes/deletes, the base64
encoding round-trip, and the transaction overhead that was only needed
to keep the two representations in sync.

* filer: address review feedback on remote deletion flow

- Distinguish missing remote config from client initialization failure
  in maybeDeleteFromRemote error messages.
- Use a detached context (30s timeout) for pending-mark and
  pending-clear KV writes so they survive request cancellation after
  the remote object has already been deleted.
- Emit NotifyUpdateEvent in reconcilePendingRemoteMetadataDeletions
  after a successful retry deletion so downstream watchers and replicas
  learn about the eventual metadata removal.

* filer: remove background reconciliation for pending remote deletions

The pending-mark/reconciliation machinery (KV index, mutex, background
loop, detached contexts) handled the narrow case where the remote
object was deleted but the subsequent local metadata delete failed.
The client already receives the error and can retry — on retry the
remote not-found is treated as success and the local delete proceeds
normally. The added complexity (and new edge cases around
NotifyUpdateEvent, multi-filer consistency during reconciliation, and
context lifetime) is not justified for a transient store failure the
caller already handles.

Remove: loopProcessingRemoteMetadataDeletionPending,
reconcilePendingRemoteMetadataDeletions, markRemoteMetadataDeletionPending,
clearRemoteMetadataDeletionPending, listPendingRemoteMetadataDeletionPaths,
encodePendingRemoteMetadataDeletionIndex, FindEntryLocal, and all
associated constants, fields, and test infrastructure.

* filer: fix test stubs and add early exit on child remote delete error

- Refactor stubFilerStore to release lock before invoking callbacks and
  propagate callback errors, preventing potential deadlocks in tests
- Implement ListDirectoryPrefixedEntries with proper prefix filtering
  instead of delegating to the unfiltered ListDirectoryEntries
- Add continue after setting err on child remote delete failure in
  doBatchDeleteFolderMetaAndData to skip further processing of the
  failed entry

* filer: propagate child remote delete error instead of silently continuing

Replace `continue` with early `break` when maybeDeleteFromRemote fails
for a child entry during recursive folder deletion. The previous
`continue` skipped the error check at the end of the loop body, so a
subsequent successful entry would overwrite err and the remote delete
error was silently lost. Now the loop breaks, the existing error check
returns the error, and NotifyUpdateEvent / chunk collection are
correctly skipped for the failed entry.

* filer: delete remote file when entry has Remote pointer, not only when remote-only

Replace IsInRemoteOnly() guard with entry.Remote == nil check in
maybeDeleteFromRemote. IsInRemoteOnly() requires zero local chunks and
RemoteSize > 0, which incorrectly skips remote deletion for cached
files (local chunks exist) and zero-byte remote objects (RemoteSize 0).
The correct condition is whether the entry has a remote backing object
at all.

---------

Co-authored-by: Chris Lu <chris.lu@gmail.com>
2026-03-12 13:16:28 -07:00
Peter Dodd 16f2269a33 feat(filer): lazy metadata pulling (#8454)
* Add remote storage index for lazy metadata pull

Introduces remoteStorageIndex, which maintains a map of filer directory
to remote storage client/location, refreshed periodically from the
filer's mount mappings. Provides lazyFetchFromRemote, ensureRemoteEntryInFiler,
and isRemoteBacked on S3ApiServer as integration points for handler-level
work in a follow-up PR. Nothing is wired into the server yet.

Made-with: Cursor

* Add unit tests for remote storage index and wire field into S3ApiServer

Adds tests covering isEmpty, findForPath (including longest-prefix
resolution), and isRemoteBacked. Also removes a stray PR review
annotation from the index file and adds the remoteStorageIdx field
to S3ApiServer so the package compiles ahead of the wiring PR.

Made-with: Cursor

* Address review comments on remote storage index

- Use filer_pb.CreateEntry helper so resp.Error is checked, not just the RPC error
- Extract keepPrev closure to remove duplicated error-handling in refresh loop
- Add comment explaining availability-over-consistency trade-off on filer save failure

Made-with: Cursor

* Move lazy metadata pull from S3 API to filer

- Add maybeLazyFetchFromRemote in filer: on FindEntry miss, stat remote
  and CreateEntry when path is under a remote mount
- Use singleflight for dedup; context guard prevents CreateEntry recursion
- Availability-over-consistency: return in-memory entry if CreateEntry fails
- Add longest-prefix test for nested mounts in remote_storage_test.go
- Remove remoteStorageIndex, lazyFetchFromRemote, ensureRemoteEntryInFiler,
  doLazyFetch from s3api; filer now owns metadata operations
- Add filer_lazy_remote_test.go with tests for hit, miss, not-found,
  CreateEntry failure, longest-prefix, and FindEntry integration

Made-with: Cursor

* Address review: fix context guard test, add FindMountDirectory comment, remove dead code

Made-with: Cursor

* Nitpicks: restore prev maker in registerStubMaker, instance-scope lazyFetchGroup, nil-check remoteEntry

Made-with: Cursor

* Fix remotePath when mountDir is root: ensure relPath has leading slash

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: decouple lazy-fetch persistence from caller context

Use context.Background() inside the singleflight closure for CreateEntry
so persistence is not cancelled when the winning request's context is
cancelled. Fixes CreateEntry failing for all waiters when the first
caller times out.

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: remove redundant Mode bitwise OR with zero

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: use bounded context for lazy-fetch persistence

Replace context.Background() with context.WithTimeout(30s) and defer
cancel() to prevent indefinite blocking and release resources.

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: use checked type assertion for singleflight result

Made-with: Cursor

* filer: rename persist context vars to avoid shadowing function parameter

Made-with: Cursor
2026-03-03 13:01:10 -08:00