Commit Graph
2 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
Chris Luandjsas 2f641a63d6 filer: honor is_moved only from ring member connections (#11456)
* filer.remote.sync: stamp entries with IF_CHUNKS_EQUAL so a stale write-back cannot delete live chunks

updateLocalEntry records the RemoteEntry stamp after an upload by writing the
event's entry back with UpdateEntry. The filer deletes every stored chunk
absent from an updated entry, so when the file was rewritten while its upload
was in flight (or the event is a replay), the stale snapshot deletes the
rewrite's chunks: the entry then points at the new fid with no needle behind
it, and the rewrite's own upload fails and is skipped as superseded.

The stamp write now carries WriteCondition IF_CHUNKS_EQUAL over the event's
chunk fids, evaluated by the filer under the path lock. A refused stamp means
the filer moved past this event; the superseding event follows in the log and
stamps the current entry, so the refusal is logged and skipped like a
superseded upload.

Reproduction: weed server -filer plus a weed server -s3 remote, remote.mount,
filer.remote.sync; hold the remote (docker pause) so one upload stays in
flight, rewrite the file through the filer, unpause. Before: the entry's chunk
is 404 on every volume server. After: the stale stamp is refused, the rewrite's
chunk stays live and reads back after a vacuum.

* filer.remote.sync: stamp entries with IF_ENTRY_EQUAL so stale inline content or metadata cannot be restored

The IF_CHUNKS_EQUAL guard compared only the chunk fid multiset, so a
rewrite that touched inline content or metadata alone still compared
equal and the stale snapshot overwrote the live entry. The new clause
compares the whole stored entry against the event's entry under the
same path lock.

* filer: route conditional UpdateEntry to the entry's owner filer

Two filers locking the same path locally could still pass a stale
condition on the non-owner while the owner's entry had moved on. When a
condition or expected_extended precondition is set, forward the request
to the entry's owner the same way conditional CreateEntry does, with
is_moved bounding the hop.

* filer: compare IF_ENTRY_EQUAL against the normalized expected entry

FindEntry grows FileSize to the chunk extent, so a raw event entry with
FileSize still zero failed the condition on an unchanged file and the
stamp was skipped, letting a replay upload the object again.

* filer.remote.sync: classify refused stamps by gRPC status only

A FailedPrecondition substring in an unrelated error would have been
swallowed as a skipped stamp; status.FromError already unwraps.

* remote sync: keep the event entry intact for IF_ENTRY_EQUAL

* filer: honor is_moved only from ring member connections

is_moved is caller-controlled, so a request could set it to skip owner
routing and run a conditional check under a non-owner's lock. Verify the
marker against the peer's connection address and the lock ring members;
an unverified marker is ignored and the request routes like a fresh one.

* filer: refuse unverifiable is_moved at a non-owner, cache ring IPs

Follow-up fixes from review on the is_moved provenance check:

- checkMovedMarker replaces "ignore and re-forward" for markers that did
  not arrive on a ring member's connection. Re-forwarding a claimed hop
  could cycle while rings disagree; instead the request is refused with
  FailedPrecondition unless this filer is the key's owner, in which case
  applying locally is correct anyway.
- ringMemberIPs caches resolved member addresses per ring membership so
  hostname-advertising deployments do not pay a DNS lookup per forwarded
  request; failed lookups are not cached so a DNS blip self-heals.
- DistributedUnlock no longer dereferences the nil response of a failed
  next-hop RPC.

* filer: refuse unverifiable is_moved with PermissionDenied, not FailedPrecondition

A routing refusal is different in kind from a write-condition mismatch:
remote sync treats FailedPrecondition as a stale stamp and skips it, so
reusing that code let a routing failure pass as synced. Owner checks now
also run before the peer-IP lookup so the common accept path does no DNS.

* filer: expire resolved ring member IPs after 5 minutes

A member's hostname can re-resolve to a new IP while its ring address
stays unchanged; caching forever would reject its genuine forwards until
a membership change or restart.

* filer: deduplicate concurrent ring member DNS lookups

At cache expiry, parallel forwarded requests would each resolve every
member hostname serially; singleflight collapses them into one lookup
per ring membership.

* filer: detach the shared ring lookup from the caller's context

The singleflight winner's ctx is cancelled when its request ends; the
shared result would then be an incomplete member list and genuine
forwards denied. The lookup now runs on a detached context with its
own deadline so a canceled caller cannot poison it.

* filer: resolve ring member hostnames in parallel

The shared lookup gave every member one serial budget, so a few slow
resolutions could leave later members out of the cached list and reject
their genuine forwards. Each member now resolves concurrently under its
own detached deadline.

* filer: gather literal member IPs before spawning lookups

A ring mixing IP literals and hostnames raced: the literal appends ran
unlocked alongside the resolver goroutines' locked appends. Split into
two passes so only hostname results share the mutex.

---------

Co-authored-by: jsas <1351492+jsas@users.noreply.github.com>
2026-09-26 19:42:23 +08:00
Chris Lu 8398af3572 filer: route exclusive and conditional creates to the entry's ring owner (#11109)
* proto: resync the java copy of filer.proto

The Makefile keeps other/java/client/src/main/proto/filer.proto a verbatim copy,
but AssignVolumeResponse.fsync and SubscribeMetadataResponse.flushed_ts_ns
landed without it. Copy them over; no behaviour change.

Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Fx1Hx8RqsJqHpbfbgTf4WJ

* filer: route exclusive and conditional creates to the entry's ring owner

CreateEntry with o_excl is a FindEntry-then-Insert. The per-path lock added for
it makes that atomic only on the filer running it, and the store's insert is an
upsert on every backend, so two filers both pass the existence check and both
report success. mkdir(2) then succeeds twice for the same path. The same hole
sits under the condition precondition, whose comment already told callers to
route the key's writes to the owner filer themselves.

Do it on the server instead, with the mechanism ObjectTransaction already uses:
resolve the entry's ring owner and forward one hop, bounded by is_moved. The
ring's membership comes from the master, so it tolerates a stale view and
reassigns when a filer dies, neither of which a client's configured filer list
can do. Every creator gets this — mount, S3, the filer's own HTTP surface, the
Java client — not only the ones that opted in.

Plain creates are upserts whoever applies them, so they stay local and pay
nothing. The route key shares the S3 gateway's namespace so an object's
ObjectTransaction and its CreateEntry land on the same filer's per-path lock.

Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Fx1Hx8RqsJqHpbfbgTf4WJ
2026-09-02 19:56:11 -07:00