mirror of
https://github.com/seaweedfs/seaweedfs.git
synced 2026-11-19 10:54:08 +01:00
Live HTTP evidence transport, continuous Loop2 service, bounded auto failover trigger, runtime-managed frontend export, bounded replica repair, end-to-end RF2 handoff with continued I/O on new primary, bounded operator HTTP surface, and CSI V2 runtime backend adapter. 11 new proof tests covering the full M6-M10 chain plus CSI create/ lookup/publish through the V2 runtime path. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2.6 KiB
2.6 KiB
V2 RF2 Runtime Bounded Envelope Review
Date: 2026-04-05
Status: draft
Purpose: record the current bounded productionization judgment for the delivered
Phase 19 RF2 working-path envelope
Review Outcome
Current decision:
stay in bounded validationnot pilot-ready
Why This Is The Correct Outcome
The delivered Phase 19 path proves one bounded working RF2 block path:
- live transport-backed evidence traffic exists
- continuous Loop 2 service exists
- bounded automatic failover exists
- runtime-managed frontend rebinding exists
- bounded repair/catch-up exists
- one real end-to-end client handoff proof exists
- bounded operator and CSI adapters now exist on top of runtime-owned truth
But the path is still not broad product/pilot approval because:
- the current proof is still bounded to the current runtime harness
- repair/catch-up is not yet broad rebuild lifecycle closure
- CSI and operator surfaces are still bounded adapters rather than full production surfaces
- no broad pilot or rollout evidence exists yet
Review Record
Reviewer reading baseline:
sw-block/.private/phase/phase-19.mdsw-block/design/v2-rf2-runtime-bounded-envelope.mdsw-block/design/v2-bounded-internal-pilot-pack.mdsw-block/design/v2-pilot-preflight-checklist.mdsw-block/design/v2-pilot-stop-conditions.mdsw-block/design/v2-controlled-rollout-review.mdsw-block/runtime/volumev2/poc_test.go
Current evidence package:
- runtime-owned failover manager
- continuous Loop 2 service and bounded auto failover
- runtime-managed frontend and bounded repair closure
- end-to-end RF2 handoff proof
- RF2 runtime surface projection and operator surface
- bounded CSI runtime backend adapter
Allowed Interpretation
The review allows only these statements:
- one runtime-bearing RF2 kernel slice now exists
- one bounded working RF2 block path now exists
- one bounded productionization artifact set now exists around that path
- later work may widen from this review only through explicit new closure
The review does NOT allow:
- working block product approval
- pilot execution against real product traffic
- rollout expansion beyond bounded internal engineering validation
Next Required Closures
Before any pilot-ready judgment can exist, the next closures must become explicit:
- multi-process / multi-host proof for the current working path
- broader rebuild lifecycle closure beyond the bounded repair wrapper
- fuller CSI lifecycle parity on the V2 runtime path
- broader operator/metrics surface closure
- pilot/preflight/containment evidence on top of the
Phase 19path