Files
seaweedfs/sw-block/design/v2-rf2-runtime-bounded-envelope-review.md
T
pingqiuandClaude Opus 4.6 044a6d770b feat: Phase 19 — bounded working RF2 block path
Live HTTP evidence transport, continuous Loop2 service, bounded auto
failover trigger, runtime-managed frontend export, bounded replica
repair, end-to-end RF2 handoff with continued I/O on new primary,
bounded operator HTTP surface, and CSI V2 runtime backend adapter.

11 new proof tests covering the full M6-M10 chain plus CSI create/
lookup/publish through the V2 runtime path.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-04-05 15:12:00 -07:00

2.6 KiB

V2 RF2 Runtime Bounded Envelope Review

Date: 2026-04-05 Status: draft Purpose: record the current bounded productionization judgment for the delivered Phase 19 RF2 working-path envelope

Review Outcome

Current decision:

  1. stay in bounded validation
  2. not pilot-ready

Why This Is The Correct Outcome

The delivered Phase 19 path proves one bounded working RF2 block path:

  1. live transport-backed evidence traffic exists
  2. continuous Loop 2 service exists
  3. bounded automatic failover exists
  4. runtime-managed frontend rebinding exists
  5. bounded repair/catch-up exists
  6. one real end-to-end client handoff proof exists
  7. bounded operator and CSI adapters now exist on top of runtime-owned truth

But the path is still not broad product/pilot approval because:

  1. the current proof is still bounded to the current runtime harness
  2. repair/catch-up is not yet broad rebuild lifecycle closure
  3. CSI and operator surfaces are still bounded adapters rather than full production surfaces
  4. no broad pilot or rollout evidence exists yet

Review Record

Reviewer reading baseline:

  1. sw-block/.private/phase/phase-19.md
  2. sw-block/design/v2-rf2-runtime-bounded-envelope.md
  3. sw-block/design/v2-bounded-internal-pilot-pack.md
  4. sw-block/design/v2-pilot-preflight-checklist.md
  5. sw-block/design/v2-pilot-stop-conditions.md
  6. sw-block/design/v2-controlled-rollout-review.md
  7. sw-block/runtime/volumev2/poc_test.go

Current evidence package:

  1. runtime-owned failover manager
  2. continuous Loop 2 service and bounded auto failover
  3. runtime-managed frontend and bounded repair closure
  4. end-to-end RF2 handoff proof
  5. RF2 runtime surface projection and operator surface
  6. bounded CSI runtime backend adapter

Allowed Interpretation

The review allows only these statements:

  1. one runtime-bearing RF2 kernel slice now exists
  2. one bounded working RF2 block path now exists
  3. one bounded productionization artifact set now exists around that path
  4. later work may widen from this review only through explicit new closure

The review does NOT allow:

  1. working block product approval
  2. pilot execution against real product traffic
  3. rollout expansion beyond bounded internal engineering validation

Next Required Closures

Before any pilot-ready judgment can exist, the next closures must become explicit:

  1. multi-process / multi-host proof for the current working path
  2. broader rebuild lifecycle closure beyond the bounded repair wrapper
  3. fuller CSI lifecycle parity on the V2 runtime path
  4. broader operator/metrics surface closure
  5. pilot/preflight/containment evidence on top of the Phase 19 path