mirror of
https://github.com/seaweedfs/seaweedfs.git
synced 2026-09-20 13:30:46 +02:00
516e251f9e
* rust volume: move the crate to edition 2024 Edition 2024 turns three things in this crate into hard errors, and changes drop order in a further 34 places without changing compilation. The compiler errors are fixed here; the silent changes were audited against `RUSTFLAGS='-W rust-2024-compatibility' cargo check --all-targets` output captured before the flip, since edition 2024 stops reporting them. `std::env::set_var`/`remove_var` are unsafe as of 2024 because they race with concurrent readers. All six call sites are safe by construction rather than by assertion, and the SAFETY comments say why: the build script runs single-threaded before anything else in the process, and every test reaching the `config.rs` helpers holds `process_state_lock()` for the duration. The two `ref` bindings in handlers.rs sit in patterns that already borrow implicitly, so removing the modifier leaves both bindings at `&String`. On the 34 drop-order sites: no lock guard's scope is extended anywhere, and `volume.rs` has none. Most are moved-from `Option`/`Result` husks — `if let Some(v) = map.remove(&k)`, `while let Some(m) = stream.next().await` — where the value is moved into the binding and the temporary has nothing left to drop; where closing order actually matters these paths already call `v.close()`, `ec_vol.destroy()` or `drop(writer)` explicitly. Two sites get strictly better ordering: the metrics read guard in `run_metrics_push_loop` shrinks to the end of its initializer block (it never crossed an `.await` either way), and an EC test now closes the volume's descriptors before the `TempDir` removes the directory. No `rust-version` is declared. Edition 2024 needs rustc 1.85, but that is not the binding constraint — the dependency tree already requires 1.91.1 through the `aws-sdk-s3`/`aws-smithy-*` family, so `cargo +1.85 check` fails on the deps regardless. CI builds on `dtolnay/rust-toolchain@stable`. `vendor/reed-solomon-erasure` is a separate package and keeps edition 2021. Cargo.lock is unchanged despite edition 2024 implying resolver 3. Verified: `cargo test` 551 passed / 0 failed, `cargo test --no-default-features` 550 passed / 0 failed (the two feature sets produce an identical migration site list), `cargo build --release` clean. No automated test covers shutdown ordering, so the channel and runtime sites in `main.rs`, `write_queue.rs` and `grpc_server.rs` were read individually. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_018nty5Rj7ssMQdFxHHjZgDC * rust volume: address edition-2024 review feedback Three fixes from review of the edition bump. Serialize the two environment-reading tests. The SAFETY comments on the `env::set_var`/`remove_var` helpers claim every test touching the environment holds `process_state_lock()`, but `test_resolve_config_defaults_dir_to_platform_temp_dir` and `test_resolve_config_index_accepts_redb_and_leveldb_aliases` called `resolve_config` — which reads HOME/USERPROFILE, SEAWEED_WRITE_QUEUE and the WEED_* set — without taking it. `set_var` is unsafe precisely because a concurrent *reader* is UB, not only a concurrent writer, so the comment was overclaiming. An audit of the module found exactly these two; every other environment-touching test already held the lock. The race predates edition 2024, which only made the requirement explicit. Declare `rust-version = "1.91.1"`. The edition needs 1.85, but that was never the binding constraint: `cargo +1.90 check --all-targets` fails on the `aws-sdk-s3`/`aws-smithy-*` family, and 1.91.1 checks clean. Declaring the verified floor turns a wall of per-dependency errors into one clear message. Cargo.lock is unchanged despite this making the resolver MSRV-aware. Update the README, which advertised "Rust 1.75+ (2021 edition)". 1.75 was already stale before this branch — the tree has needed 1.91 for a while. Verified: `cargo test` 551 passed / 0 failed, `cargo test --no-default-features` 550 passed / 0 failed, `cargo build --release` clean. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_018nty5Rj7ssMQdFxHHjZgDC * rust volume: state the exact MSRV patch release in the README The README said "Rust 1.91+", which reads as 1.91.0 and is wrong by one patch release: `cargo +1.91.0 check --all-targets` fails on the aws-sdk-s3 family, `cargo +1.91.1` passes. Say 1.91.1+, matching `rust-version` in Cargo.toml, and call out that the patch component is load-bearing so nobody installs 1.91.0 and hits the same wall. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_018nty5Rj7ssMQdFxHHjZgDC * rust worker: move the workspace to edition 2024 Moves the seaweed-worker workspace (core, lance, sort) from edition 2021 to 2024, the same migration seaweed-volume just got in this branch. Edition 2024 turns exactly one thing in this workspace into a hard error. The baseline came from RUSTFLAGS='-W rust-2024-compatibility' cargo check --all-targets, run before the flip; unlike seaweed-volume's 34 silent + 8 hard sites, the worker reports only the one hard site and no tail_expr_drop_order or if_let_rescope sites at all. The worker is a much smaller crate and none of its expressions hold a guard or temporary whose drop order the edition changes, so there is nothing to audit on the silent side. Fixed (1 site): std::env::set_var is unsafe as of 2024 because it races with concurrent readers. The single call is in crates/core/build.rs, which sets PROTOC from protoc_bin_vendored the way seaweed-volume's build script does. A build script's main runs single-threaded before anything else in the process, so no other thread can be reading the environment concurrently; the SAFETY comment says so. There are no config.rs-style test helpers here -- the worker's tests do not mutate the environment -- so unlike the volume crate there are no process_state_lock() callers to audit. No redundant ref bindings to clean up: a grep for ref across the three crates finds none. MSRV: rust-version = "1.94.1", verified rather than inferred. Edition 2024 only needs 1.85, but the dependency tree needs more: lance's aws feature pulls in a newer cut of the same aws-sdk-*/aws-smithy-* family that sets seaweed-volume's 1.91.1 floor, and that newer cut requires 1.94.1. cargo +1.94.0 check --all-targets fails on that family; cargo +1.94.1 check --all-targets is clean. The worker's floor is therefore higher than the volume's, and moves with lance and the AWS SDK rather than with the edition. CI builds on dtolnay/rust-toolchain@stable, so nothing changes there. The edition is set once in [workspace.package] and inherited by each member via edition.workspace = true; rust-version is added the same way. The workspace keeps its explicit resolver = "2" -- edition 2024 would default to resolver 3, but the pin is deliberate and Cargo.lock is unchanged by this commit either way. The README gains a "Requires Rust 1.94.1+ (2024 edition)" line in its Building section, matching the one seaweed-volume's README now carries, and calling out that the patch release is load-bearing (1.94.0 does not build) so nobody installs 1.94.0 and hits the same wall. Verification: * cargo check --all-targets -- clean, zero warnings (default toolchain 1.97) * cargo +1.94.1 check --all-targets -- clean * cargo +1.94.0 check --all-targets -- fails on the AWS SDK, as claimed * cargo test --all-targets -- 40 passed, 0 failed (core 13, sort 11, lance lib 3, lance bin 2, compaction 6, lifecycle 1, sort integration 4) * Cargo.lock unchanged Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Co-authored-by: Chris Lu <chris.lu@gmail.com>